Top 7 Must-Try East Hampton Restaurants for Foodies

Top 7 Must-Try East Hampton Restaurants for Foodies

East Hampton is more than just a jaw-dropping beach destination—it's a culinary hot spot you can't afford to miss! Are you a dedicated foodie or just someone on the hunt for a memorable meal? Either way, East Hampton delivers big on flavor. Hungry for some of the most mouthwatering dishes you'll ever try? Let's dive into it, because discovering Restaurants in East Hampton is an adventure to experience!

Here are the top 7 must try restaurants you can't miss:

1. The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn is where vintage charm and culinary innovation come together. Your taste adventure starts with the Montauk fluke tartare, a zesty blend of spice, tangy cucumber, and a dash of wasabi that wakes up your palate. If you're aiming for something lighter, consider the heirloom & sungold tomato salad, a vibrant dish that marries the crispness of fresh tomatoes with the rich undertones of smoked bacon and focaccia crumbs.

When it comes to main courses, the Maine dayboat halibut is a crowd-pleaser. The fish is enhanced by a rich mushroom and thyme ragout, and a velvety layer of Yukon gold potato purée brings it all together. For swordfish enthusiasts, there's the East Coast swordfish, prepared "salmoriglio" style. This involves marinating the fish in a zesty lemon and marjoram sauce and serving it alongside nourishing baby kale and fingerling potatoes.

In a nutshell, The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn is your go-to for a dining experience that is both cozy and adventurous.

2. Bostwick's Chowder House: 

At Bostwick's Chowder House, the allure of the ocean is everywhere, right down to the nautical decor. Choose to dine indoors, or soak up the laid-back atmosphere under patio umbrellas. Even better, grab your seafood favorites to go and make the beach your dining room. On the menu, you'll find seafood classics like New England clam chowder and lobster bisque that taste like they're straight from the ocean – and with prices that won't break the bank.

If raw seafood is your go to, there are options such as the littleneck and cherrystone clams, and fresh oysters. Come for the seafood; stay for the atmosphere – Bostwick's Chowder House has it all.

3. Sam's: 

Sam's is the real deal when it comes to Italian-American food in East Hampton. Operating since 1947, this restaurant has that classic feel to it and dishes that have stood the test of time. Locals love it, and summer visitors quickly find out why it's been a go-to spot for decades.

You can't go wrong starting your meal with their homemade soup. If you're more in the mood for something with a kick, try the baked clams or the steamed mussels, served in a white wine, garlic, and basil sauce. When it comes to salads, Sam's has a lot of options, from a simple house salad with italian dressing to something more fancy like the rosaline salad that includes marinated mushrooms and artichokes. The Greek salad is a crowd-pleaser, featuring feta cheese and kalamata olives on a bed of red leaf lettuce. 

Whether you're a local or just in town for a visit, you have to check out Sam's. 

4. Nick & Toni's: 

Nick & Toni's in East Hampton is a culinary hotspot that brings the Mediterranean right to your table. The restaurant's farm-to-table ethos ensures that you're getting the freshest ingredients, whether that's in a classic pasta dish or one of their famous wood-fired pizzas. Starting with their "For the Table" options, the rustic sourdough paired with olives is a delicious way to kick off your meal. If you're looking for something a bit more indulgent, their zucchini fritto is a crowd-pleaser.

Cheese lovers will appreciate the artisanal cheese selection, complete with marcona almonds, dried fruit toast, and housemade jam. The montauk yellowfin tuna crudo is another standout, featuring watermelon radish and amagansett sea salt. If you're into grilled food, don't skip the wood grilled octopus paired with a unique Sicilian purple potato salad. 

All in all, Nick & Toni's delivers a sophisticated dining experience with dishes that celebrate the flavors of the Mediterranean. It's no wonder this spot is so popular!

5. Rowdy Hall: 

Rowdy Hall in East Hampton is another great one from Restaurants in East Hampton. It combines the cozy feel of an English pub with the classy touch of a French bistro. Here, you can find a wide range of dishes, from filling meals to lighter options. It's a great place to enjoy different flavors all in one spot.

Starting with salads, the smr smith's salad features a satisfying blend of chopped iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, and cucumbers, drizzled with a well-balanced dressing of olive oil and red wine vinegar. If you love soup, Rowdy Hall has a couple of great choices. Their summer corn chowder is filled with potatoes, bacon, spicy peppers, and tomatoes, making it a tasty and filling option. Of course, the option for something more traditional is also available, with dishes like the french onion soup. It is made with a rich meaty broth and sweet onions, then topped with toasted bread and melted cheese.

Whether you're in the mood for a big, juicy burger or a light, fresh salad, Rowdy Hall has something for everyone.

6. Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House: 

At Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House, expect high-quality dining that's crafted to impress. Chef Jean-Georges pays close attention to every ingredient, turning each dish into a memorable experience. For those who love caviar, the egg toast caviar is a must-try. It pairs fine caviar with soft brioche and chives, creating a rich flavor you won't forget. Seafood enthusiasts will appreciate the fresh east coast oysters, served with tangy cocktail sauce and mignonette. For an extra special touch, go for the petrossian caviar. It's presented with warm blini pancakes and a chive cream.

In short, Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House is the perfect place if you're looking to treat yourself.

7. The Springs Tavern: 

At The Springs Tavern, you can relax with live music while enjoying good American food. If you like seafood, the steamed mussels are a must-try. They're cooked in garlic herb butter and white wine, making them really tasty. For those who like a little spice, the spicy tuna tartare is a good pick. It has high-quality tuna marinated in a sriracha sesame sauce that adds a nice kick.

And don't miss the crispy calamari. They're fried until they're golden and come with marinara sauce and sriracha mayo for dipping. All in all, The Springs Tavern is a great place to eat and relax, and the live music makes it even better.


There you have it! This spot offers a variety of dining experiences, from the classic elegance of East Hampton grill to the vibrant flavors of Restaurants in East Hampton.

Whether you want to indulge in culinary delights or seek adventure with things to do in the Hamptons, there's something here for you. Don't miss the charm of Amagansett restaurants or luxurious retreats such as the East Hampton house resort. 

As you savor every bite and explore every corner, remember that this place is more than just a destination – it's an invitation to discover the heart and soul of this coastal haven. 

Exclusive Presentation by Resident Publications.

Become an Insider!  Step into the world of luxury with RESIDENT Magazine. Click here to subscribe to our exclusive newsletter and gain unparalleled access to the latest in luxury lifestyle, high-end real estate, travel exclusives, and so much more.

Are you interested in advertising with Resident? Email us at to learn more.

Related Stories

No stories found.
Resident Magazine